The Limits of the Lean Startup Method
- by 7wData
Advocates of the lean startup method for creating a business advise entrepreneurs, as well as corporate intrapreneurs, to document, test, and refine their assumptions about a new venture’s business model via customer conversations and experiments. My recent research on 250 teams that participated in an American cleantech accelerator program during the last 10 years found that while the lean approach can be effective, having a strong strategy is more important than conducting a tremendous number of market tests.
First, the good news: In general, the lean startup method works. We measured success by looking at how teams performed in a pitch competition in front of a panel of industry experts at the end of the accelerator program (a proxy, albeit an imperfect one, for long-term financial performance). Teams that elucidated and then tested hypotheses about their venture performed almost three times better in the pitch competition than teams that did not test any hypotheses.
Now, the bad news: There was no linear relationship between the number of validated hypotheses and a team’s subsequent success. In short, more validation is not better. I also found that teams that conducted both open-ended conversations and more formalized experiments with customers actually performed worse in the competition than teams that conducted either one or the other during the early stages of venture design.
One possible explanation for the diminishing and even negative return on customer interaction is an erosion of confidence: too much feedback from customers might cause the entrepreneurs to change the idea so frequently that they become disheartened. Another possibility is that the lean startup method, while efficient compared to the conventional approach of “build it and they will come,” still requires time, attention, and resources that are diverted from other projects.;
[Social9_Share class=”s9-widget-wrapper”]
Upcoming Events
Shift Difficult Problems Left with Graph Analysis on Streaming Data
29 April 2024
12 PM ET – 1 PM ET
Read MoreYou Might Be Interested In
Six Lessons From Amsterdam’s Smart City Initiative
14 Nov, 2016The city of Amsterdam has long been known for its canals, cafés, and bicycling culture. In recent years, though, it’s …
The fourth industrial revolution in agriculture
12 Oct, 2019Do all cows’ faces look the same to you? They don’t to systems powered by artificial intelligence (AI). Bovine facial …
What Managers Need to Know About Data Exchanges
18 Jul, 2020The era of big-data silos is fading. Shared data is the future. The idea that many businesses rely heavily on …
Recent Jobs
Do You Want to Share Your Story?
Bring your insights on Data, Visualization, Innovation or Business Agility to our community. Let them learn from your experience.